Conservative Congressional Faction Thwarts McCarthy’s Government Shutdown Bill

GOP Hardliners Defeat McCarthy Government Shutdown Bill, Risking Longer Closure

An Unexpected Defeat

The Speaker of the House, Kevin McCarthy, faced an unexpected defeat as hardline members of his own party voted against his plan to keep the government open for 31 days past the October 1 shutdown deadline. This defeat not only increases the likelihood of a lengthy federal closure but also deprives the House GOP of a settled list of demands to end the impending shutdown.

The vote, which resulted in a 232 to 198 defeat, saw 21 Republicans joining Democrats in rejecting the measure. This embarrassing loss for McCarthy not only further complicates negotiations with President Joe Biden and the Democratic Senate but also allows Democrats to portray the shutdown as purely driven by GOP chaos.

The Impact on House Republicans

The failed vote is expected to cost House Republicans “a lot of leverage” in negotiations, according to GOP Representative Steve Womack of Arkansas. This loss reflects an internal division within the GOP and raises questions about the party’s ability to effectively govern.

Financial markets, however, have not been significantly impacted by the growing risk of a shutdown. Investors continue to focus on other factors such as high interest rates, rising oil prices, labor strikes, and slowing consumer spending. Nonetheless, the clash between hardline GOP members and the party’s leadership is raising concerns over the dysfunction of the US government and may have long-term consequences for America’s standing with investors.

A Potential Government Shutdown

While financial markets may not be overly concerned at the moment, a government shutdown could have serious economic consequences. Initially, the impact may be mild, but it would gradually build as millions of workers go without pay, private contractors remain unpaid, and consumer uncertainty grows.

McCarthy‘s short-term spending bill, unveiled in the early hours of Friday, proposed temporary funding cuts of 30% for most government agencies. It also included new asylum and immigration restrictions that are fundamentally opposed by Democrats. Additionally, the bill aimed to establish a deficit commission to study cuts in Social Security, Medicare, and other entitlements. Despite these provisions, a group of ultraconservatives within the GOP remained steadfast in their opposition to any temporary funding to keep the government open.

Even if the bill had passed the House, its sharp cuts and border provisions would have made it toxic in the Senate. The ultraconservative members who led the opposition to the bill prefer a different approach. They want the House to vote on 12 individual spending bills and reconcile them with the Senate, a process that could take many weeks and further complicate matters as not all of these bills can pass in the GOP-controlled Senate.

The Ouster of McCarthy and Potential Congressional Action

The effort to defeat the short-term measure was led by hardline Florida Representative Matt Gaetz, a fierce opponent of Speaker McCarthy. Gaetz is now preparing to try to oust McCarthy from his role, although the prospects of success are uncertain. Democrats could potentially save McCarthy if they offer their support.

With the House stalled, attention turns to the Senate in hopes of limiting the length of the impending shutdown. Senators are currently working on a bipartisan bill that would fund the government for 47 days and provide $6 billion in aid to Ukraine and $6 billion in disaster aid. Despite some procedural hurdles, it is likely that the Senate will approve this bill on Sunday, just hours after the shutdown deadline.

However, McCarthy has promised his GOP conference that he will not allow a vote on the Senate bill as written. This stance could change if the bill is amended. A bipartisan group, including independent Senator Kyrsten Sinema, moderate Democrat Joe Manchin, and Republican leaders, is working on a possible amendment to add up to $6 billion in border security funding. This addition could potentially allow McCarthy to put the bill on the floor for a vote with minimal Democratic support, as it would only require 51 votes in the Senate.

The decision McCarthy faces is a difficult one. If he allows a vote on the Senate bill, it could easily pass the House with Democratic support, but it would likely trigger the Gaetz-led effort to oust him from his position. On the other hand, if McCarthy refuses to bring the bill to a vote, moderate Republicans have stated their intent to use a House process called a discharge petition to force a vote to reopen the government. This process could take at least nine days to play out.

The Road Ahead

The defeat of McCarthy‘s spending bill highlights the challenges facing not only the GOP but also the entire government. Divisions within the Republican party, coupled with the need for bipartisan support in the Senate, present significant hurdles that must be overcome to prevent a prolonged government shutdown.

As negotiations shift to the Senate, all eyes will be on whether McCarthy can find a solution that will satisfy both hardline members of his party and the Democrats. The outcome of these negotiations will have consequences not only for the government’s ability to function but also for the economic stability of the country.

It is essential for policymakers to remember that government shutdowns have real-world impacts on workers, contractors, and the overall economy. The longer this political deadlock continues, the greater the repercussions will be felt by individuals and businesses across the nation.

—
Keywords: Politics-conservative, congressional faction, McCarthy, government shutdown, bill